Sleep, Health and Immunocompetence: A Review
NKD
Devi*, C Srilatha,
KVSR
ABSTRACT:
Despite a century of study, we have a very
little understanding of why we sleep? And it is most surprising to know that we
spend nearly one third of our lives in sleep. Scientists found out another
important function for sleep. It actually prepares our emotional brain for next
day social and emotional interactions. Sleep and Immune system are very much
related to each other. Generally we feel sleepier when we are suffering from
infection and it is believed that sleep deprivation can prone us to more
infections. The sleep deprivation causes a lot of irregularities in the levels
of cytokines as well as hormones. Are sleep and immune system really
related? This is the point to be
discussed in this review. To understand this relation a basic study on sleep
and immune system components is necessary.
KEY
WORDS: NREM sleep and REM
sleep, Immune system, IL-1β, TNF.
INTRODUCTION:
SLEEP:
SLEEP is a state of unconsciousness in which
internal stimuli influence the brain more than external stimuli .The regulatory
switch for sleep was considered to be a venterolateral preoptic nucleus of
anterior hypothalamus. (Fig-1)
A good night’s sleep consists of two
distinct cycles; Rapid eye movement sleeps [REMS] and non rapid eye movement
sleep [NREMS]. REM sleep is also called as dream sleep. These NREMS and REMS
are defined by electroencephalographic (EEG) brain wave patterns, the amount of
eye movement, brain temperature by using EEG electrodes, electromyographic
electrodes and thermistors applied in or near the brain respectively.
NREM sleep is characterized by 4 stages:
stage-1, stage-2, stage-3, and stage-4.
These stages occur in a cyclic process
throughout the night (4-5) cycles. The duration for each cycle has been
identified ranging between 60-90 minutes. A normal human sleep cycle starts
with NREM stage1, stage2, 3, 4 and progresses to REMS. When compared with REM
sleep and wakefulness, NREM sleep has greater amplitudes and lower frequencies
of brain, eye and muscle waves.
Features of NREM sleep:
Stage-1: It is considered to be a transition state
between wakefulness and sleep. When a person closes his eyes, NREM sleep begins
and is followed by several sudden sharp muscle contractions in leg, then
relaxation .This period lasts for 3-12 minutes.
Stage-2: In this stage, frequency of the EEG decreases
and amplitude increases. A series of high frequency waves known as sleep
spindles interrupt the theta waves of this stage and they last for 1-2 seconds.
Thalamic and cortical neurons interact and generate these waves. High amplitude
forms called k-complex are shown
during this stage in EEG traces. This stage constitutes about 50% of total time
in sleep each night in adults.
Stage-3: This is the stage from moderate to true
deep sleep (sws).A delta wave first appears, sleep spindles and k-complexes
occur and this stage lasts for 10 minutes during the first sleep cycle and
represents only 7% of the total night’s
sleep.
Stage-4: This is the deepest NREM sleep. The EEG
trace is dominated by delta waves and overall neutral activity is at its
lowest. Breathing, heart rate, B.P and brain’s temperature are all reduced
under the influence of para sympathetic nervous system. This is also the stage
in which children may have episodes of somnambulism or sleep walking and night
terrors.
REM sleep:
It is called dream sleep or paradoxical sleep. It
constitutes about 20-25% of total sleeping time. During REMS memory is
refreshed. A person will experience 4 to 5 periods of REM sleep during night.
EEG recording of neural activity during REM shows almost the same tracing as to
that during this period.
Effect of infection on sleep:
Sleep deprivation may produce varying effects ranging
from lowered immune system, memory, gain of weight. During an infection, the
brain activates the peripheral immune system. The neurons in the brain which
regulate sleep are also related to the immune system. The brain functions by
bringing a change in physiological processes to fight off the bacterial and
viral infection. One of such approach is release of cytokines which also found
to influence the increased sleep during infections. During an acute infection,
the NREM increases. This may also be because of increase in concentration of
IL-beta
Common cold (6) is one of the most simple of
infections of which everybody are aware of. During infection we feel
uncomfortable may be of the breathing problem or fatigue or urge to sleep. But,
when do we feel better (less discomfortable) that is during morning, after a
good night sleep. This suggests sleep to be a better alternative than medicines
during cold. The conditions degrade eventually and gets worse by evening. Short
naps during the day may prove helpful which may be because during sleep the
immune system gets activated or reenergized to fight against the infection and
this is shown by few evidences.
Evidence to show an increase
in sleep during infection:
Several experiments were conducted on both animals and
humans but it is difficult to integrate the results as the immune parameters
vary from species to species.
Animals:
A change in sleep patterns occurred when toth.et.al
conducted a range of experiments by infecting animals with various micro
organisms like viral infection of mice with influenza, fungal infection of
rabbits with candida albicans and protozoan infection of rabbits(fig-3) with
trypanasoma brucei(5). Some animals specifically showed an increase
in SWS duration and amplitude in a diseased condition called trypanosomiasi.
The release of parasites in to blood stream is associated with increase in SWS
although over all there is a decrease in SWS.
Fig-3: experimenting on rabbits by infecting them with
micro organisms
Humans:
Viral infection with influenza virus causes sleep
alterations although the quality of sleep is unaffected. A decreased sleep
duration was observed on infection with rhinovirus. Administration of animal
products like LPS causes a decrease in REM sleep but increases SWS duration,
increases body temperature, heart rate, level of cytokines (TNF).
In a certain case called human African trypanosomniasis
sleeping sickness both sleep disturbances and immune disorders occur. It was
found out that the level of disturbance is directly proportional to the
severity of illness.
In some cases of HIV, an increased duration of SWS
during the latter half of the night occurs. But it is not clear whether all the
infections cause an increase in sleep time. For example, in infants with mild
respiratory tract infections, they did not show any increased sleep time or
altered sleep proportions.
Role of cytokines in sleep:
Certain group of proteins called cytokines (9, 11,
12, 13) present in our body act as connecting link between immune system
and central nervous system. These cytokines concentration increases during
night and evidences have shown that they are included in normal sleep wake
regulation. To know their effects on sleep almost nearly 20 proteins have been
studied among which interleukin-1 (IL-1) and tumor necrosis factor (TNF)(10)
are found to influence the NREMS of mammals.
It has been observed through molecular genetics, electro
physiological and biochemical studies that a reduction in NREM sleep occurs if
the IL-1 and TNF systems are antagonized and also an increase in NREM sleep
occurs when the body experiences antigenic challenge which may be due to the
increased concentration of IL-1and TNF. These cytokines are identified as two
types, proinflammatory (type-1) and anti-inflammatory (type-2). The receptors
for these cytokines are located on the hypothalamic nuclei and brainstem. Older
people generally suffer from less amount of sleep. One of the reasons is the
increased levels of IL-6 and cortisol. They also influence ACTH, GH secretion.
Scientific studies have revealed that IL-2, IL-15,
IL-18, IFN-alpha and IFN-gamma usually increase duration of sleep and IL-4,
IL-10 and IL-13 inhibit spontaneous sleep. Mostly pro-inflammatory cytokines
promote sleep and anti-inflammatory cytokines tend to inhibit.
Certain cytokines like IL-1 and TNF act on certain
regions of brain which also regulate sleep. Sleep active neurons present in the
preoptic area of the anterior hypothalamus are stimulated by both IL-1 and TNF.
IL-1 enhances adenosine levels in hippocampus and
prostaglandin D2 (PGD2) synthesis both of which (ADENOSINE and PGD2) are known
as sleep regulatory substances. The IL-1β (fig-4) and TNF-α are
involved in regulation of sleep even without infection.
There exists an innate relation between sleep and other
systems in our body like nervous system, immune system, endocrine system,
circadian system etc.
SLEEP AND ENDOCRINE SYSTEM:
The endocrine system was found to play an important
role as a connecting link between immune system and sleep through harmones.
Hypothalamus produces corticotropin releasing harmone (CRH) a potent inducer of
waking. Another important harmone is Growth harmone releasing harmone (GHRH).
It promotes NREM sleep and its concentration was found to be highest in night.
Growth harmone enhances tissue growth and protien anbolism and its synthesis is
promoted by GHRH and Ghrelin. Cortisol inhibits the synthesis of IL-1 and few
cytokines where as GHRH promotes it.
If GH secretion is supressed, it can lead to sleep
supression. Eg:- Insulin like growth
factor (IGF-1).An increase in cortisol might be the reason for disrupted
sleep causes in adult. A decrease in SWS was observed when cortisol levels are
increased. Prolactin is also found in its highest concentration during sleep.
Somatostatin found in REMS, reduces NREMS and GH. Vasopressin was found to be
useful in increasing REM, SWS and sleep time. In a study on rabbits, they are
injected with 1nmol/kg centrally and it caused an increased time in NREMS i.e.
a period of 53 minutes (during 1st 6 hrs of injection).
CIRCADIAN SYSTEM:
There is an internal clock in our body which controls
our sleep wake cycle. This circadian rhythm is modulated by hypothalamus. To be
mentioned specifically it is called suprachiasmatic nucleus. These rhythms are
light influenced. This can be one of the reasons for blind people to experience
lifelong sleeping problems as their retinas are unable to detect light. One of
the important aspects of sleep is circadian rhythmicity. If the immune system
components are varied by light cycle it might support a link between immune
system and sleep. During sleep, levels of lymphocytes and monocytes reach
maximum and are lowest after waking. At night plasma TNF levels increase but it
has been observed that during a sleep disorder like OBSTRUCTIVE SLEEP- APNOEA,
the circadian rhythm of TNF was found to be disrupted. Also in rats it was
shown that the magnitude of increase in SWS in response to IL-beta is dependent
on circadian phase of administration.
EFFECT OF SLEEP DEPRIVATION ON
IMMUNE SYSTEM (4):
During sleep, every physiological variable changes
relative to wakefulness, so it is not possible to isolate sleep as a separate
variable and study its effects .So the animal
is sleep deprived and its effect on the immune system are studied to
understand the complex relation of sleep and immune system.
A protein known as Dimuramyl
peptide accumulates in the body in the spinal fluid especially, when the
animal is sleep deprived. The protein is not synthesised by the body and is
secreted by bacteria. This indicates that sleep deprivation enhances bacterial
growth. Not only that, they are also found to increase the NREM sleep. To get a
better view of cytokines role in sleep, study of effects of sleep deprivation
might be useful.
Experimental studies have shown that a change in the
immune cell number occurred after sleep deprivation. They concluded that
T-helper cells and NK cells decrease in number after 40 hrs of sleep
deprivation and their number increases after 64 hrs deprivation which shows the
importance of duration of sleep deprivation. Furthermore studies revealed controversial
results. With shorter periods of sleep deprivation, the cell lytic activity of
natural killer cells has decreased but the same activity increased during
longer periods of sleep deprivation. Another study showed that in subjects who
were sleep deprived for 72 hrs, a decrease in phagocytosis occurred.
A study in humans reported a decrease in the level of
immunoglobulins on sleep deprivation, but this result has not been reproduced.
The cytokine IL-6 levels increase on onset of sleep.
When sleep is delayed the concentration does not rise, it rises only when sleep
begins. So if a person is sleep deprived, he must have normal levels of IL-6,
on the contrary it was found that there is an increase in concentration of IL-6
than the normal individuals. This develops an urge to sleep indicating that
cytokines play a part in promoting sleep.
Hormones particularly are found to be non-influential
regarding the immune changes occurring with sleep deprivation. In an experiment
conducted on mice, they are immunized against infection with influenza virus
and then sleep deprived. When they are attacked by virus, they did not clear
the virus efficiently. They acted similarly as that of unimmunised mice, but on
further experiments these results are not reproduced. Another contrary effect
observed is that in non-immune mice .sleep deprivation decreased the progress
rate of influenza virus along respiratory tract.
When extreme sleep deprivation is considered in rats
which were sleep deprived for 21 days, they developed Cachenia and Septicaemia
where as in humans sleep deprivation did not show an increase in infections due
to several reasons.
In another study, effects of sleep deprivation is
studied by measuring the amount of stress produced .It was found that rats
which are REMS deprived develop stress harmone response like increased
corticosterone levels and decreased testosterone levels. These responses are
similar to that of the rats which are given foot shock, a potent stressor.
Stress ulcers are observed in rats with sub acute sleep deprivation.
In an experiment, certain subjects are subjected to
sleep loss of 15, 39 and 63 hours and then made asleep. During deprivation an
increase in the levels of IL-1β was observed and on recovery a decrease
than the normal baseline levels was observed. The levels of IL-6 fluctuated
during sleep deprivation and decrease on recovery.
In another study of human volunteers, they provided an
extensive sleep loss in simulated spaceflight conditions, than increase in
soluble TNF-α receptors and IL-6 was observed.
In order to find out the role of cytokines in sleep,
certain cytokines or certain cytokine receptors were blocked and the effect it
produces on sleep were observed. A decrease in spontaneous REMS was observed
due to the absence of type-1 IFN receptor but no effect was produced on NREMS.
Both acute and chronic intermittent sleep deprivation
exacerbates colonic inflammation. This is shown by experimenting on a mouse
model of colitis. It worsens the inflammation and delays recovery.
SLEEP DISORDERS:
In few clinical conditions both disordered sleep and
disordered immune functions occur which provide evidence of their relation.
CONCLUSION:
Sleep and Immune system are very much related to each
other. Mainly many cytokines like interleukins and TNF influences REM and NREM
sleep. Most of the proinflammatory and anti inflammatory cytokines regulates
sleep by means of regulating adenosine and PGD2 levels. Even the endocrine
system and circadian system also have relationship with sleep. The sleep
deprivation causes a lot of irregularities in the levels of cytokines as well
as hormones.
REFERENCES:
1. Zimmerman JE, Naidoo N, Raizen DM, Pack AI. Conservation of sleep:
insights from non-mammalian model systems. Trends Neurosci. 2008; 31:371–376.
2. Recombinant tumor necrosis factor and
interleukin 1 enhance slow-wave sleep. Shoham, S., Davenne, D., Cady, A. B.,
Dinarello, C. A. and Krueger, J. M Am. J. Physiol. 253, R142–R149 (1987).
3. Krueger JM, Majde JA. Sleep as a
host defense: its regulation by microbial products and cytokines. Clin Immunol
Immunopathol. 1990;57:188–199.
4. Born, J., Lange, T., Hansen, K., Molle, M. and
Fehm, H. L. Effects of sleep and circadian rhythm on human circulating immune
cells. J. Immunol. 158, 4454–4464 (1997).
5.
Toth, L. A., Tolley, E. A., Broady, R., Blakely, B. and Krueger, J. M.
Sleep during experimental trypanosomiasis
in rabbits. Proc. Soc. Exp. Biol. Med. 205, 174–181 (1994).
6.
Drake, C. L. et al. Effects of an experimentally induced rhinovirus
cold on sleep, performance, and daytime alertness. Physiol. Behav. 71, 75–81
(2000).
7.
Vitkovic, L., Bockaert, J. and Jacque, C. 'Inflammatory' cytokines:
neuromodulators in normal brain? J. Neurochem. 74, 457–471 (2000).
8.
Takahashi, S., Kapas, L., Fang, J. and Krueger, J. M. An anti-tumor
necrosis factor antibody suppresses sleep in rats and rabbits. Brain Res. 690,
241–244 (1995).
9.
Opp, M. R., Smith, E. M. and Hughes, T. K. Jr. Interleukin-10 (cytokine
synthesis inhibitory factor) acts in the central nervous system of rats to
reduce sleep. J. Neuroimmunol. 60, 165–168 (1995).
10. Takahashi, S., Kapas, L.,
Fang, J. and Krueger, J. M. Somnogenic relationships between tumor necrosis
factor and interleukin-1. Am. J. Physiol. 276, R1132–R1140 (1999).
11. Kubota, T., Brown, R. A.,
Fang, J. and Krueger, J. M. Interleukin-15 and interleukin-2 enhance non-REM
sleep in rabbits. Am. J. Physiol. Regul. Integr. Comp. Physiol. 281,
R1004–R1012 (2001).
12. Kushikata, T., Fang, J. and
Krueger, J. M. Interleukin-10 inhibits spontaneous sleep in rabbits. J.
Interferon Cytokine Res. 19, 1025–1030 (1999).
13. Hogan, D., Morrow, J. D.,
Smith, E. M. and Opp, M. R. Interleukin-6 alters sleep of rats. J.
Neuroimmunol. 137, 59–66 (2003).
Received on 03.12.2009
Accepted on 15.01.2010
© A&V Publication all right reserved
Research J. Pharmacology and
Pharmacodynamics 2(2): March –April 2010: 148-152