An Overview on Plant-Based Polyphenols Antidiabetic agent for their Potential Pharmacological and Pathophysiological Mechanism
Arjun Singh1*, Hemant Sehgal2, Priyanka Kumari2, Sachin Sharma2, Divya Sharma2,
Akanksha Singh2
1Department of Medicine, Sidney Kimmel Medical College,
Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, PA 19107, United States.
2Department of Pharmacognosy, School of Pharmaceutical Sciences,
Bhagwant University, Sikar Road, Ajmer, Rajasthan 305004, India.
*Corresponding Author E-mail: arjunphar@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
Recent studies shown that the data of clinical, experimental and epidemiological studies indicates that dietary phytoestrogens, flavonoids and polyphenolic compounds have shown most potent activities for prevention in diabetes. The major class of compounds found in phytoestrogen. Diabetes mellitus (DM) is a common endocrine metabolic disorder. Oral anti-diabetic drugs, in addition to exercise and diet, have been used as part of the global management strategy. Unfortunately, no conventional anti-diabetic drug is without side effects, and these drugs are expensive. As a result, researchers face a significant challenge in investigating novel anti-diabetic regimens, with nature serving as the primary resource for the discovery of potential therapeutics. Many plants have been shown to act as anti-diabetic agents, with polyphenols being the main active constituents. Natural products with high polyphenol levels can regulate carbohydrate metabolism through a variety of mechanisms, including protecting and restoring beta-cell integrity, increasing insulin releasing activity, and increasing cellular metabolism. Based on the intriguing results of various studies, prophylactic and therapeutic potential of antidiabetic friendly natural products have been suggested.
KEYWORDS: Diabetes, Natural products, Phytoestrogen, Herbal medicine.
INTRODUCTION:
The majority of diabetic patients live in low and middle-income countries, and the incidence of diabetes among those with low income is expected to rise over the next 22 years3. Traditionally, the presence or absence of insulin dependence in a patient determines the classification of their diabetes. Recent research has identified five types of diabetes mellitus (DM) and their etiopathogenetic mechanisms: type 1A (auto-immune mediated), type 1B (idiopathic or nonauto- immune mediated), type 2 (insulin resistance), gestational (first recognized during pregnancy but typically characterized by insulin resistance), and type 5 (other specific aetiologies; secondary to other diseases and recognized gene mutations)4. Although T2DM's immediate symptoms may be inconsequential and barely interfere with daily activities, the complications that result in the impairment of vital organs have the potential to be significantly more morbid and lethal5-15.
METHODS:
Materials:
A search for articles published in peer-reviewed journals using electronic databases such as PubMed, Scopus, Science Direct, and Google Scholar. It was used to collect data on various plant-based anti-diabetic agents that have historically been used for pharmacologically based treatment, ethnomedicinal, phytochemical, and other disorders.
Patients who experience failure during initial therapy typically need medication. In general, patients who don't respond to the initial therapy need medication. No oral medication, however, can be regarded as the best course of treatment due to their extensive lists of side effects, high prices, and occasionally attenuated responses after prolonged use. For instance, sulphonylurea typically results in hypoglycemia, skin rash, or itching, whereas the widely used anti-diabetic medication metformin causes lactic acidosis, general sickness, and alcohol use. Additionally, alpha-glucosidase inhibitors have been linked to bloating, diarrhea, and hypoglycemia, meglitinides to weight gain and hypoglycemia, and thiazolidinediones to liver disease risk17.
To overcome the difficulties associated with existing synthetic oral hypoglycemic agents, a search for novel targets or newer drugs is required. As a result of their traditional use, several phytoconstituents and phyto-products have emerged as potential alternative sources for developing new antioxidant and anti-diabetic agents. There are approximately 200 pure compounds isolated from plant sources with blood glucose lowering activity, fewer side effects, and low costs18.
Polyphenols are secondary metabolites that are generally involved in the defense against ultraviolet radiation or pathogen infection. Epidemiological studies and associated meta-analyses from the early twenty-first century strongly suggested that long-term consumption of plant polyphenol-rich diets offered some resistance against the development of diabetes, cancers, osteoporosis, cardiovascular disease, and neurodegenerative diseases. Polyphenols and phenolic compounds inhibit glucose absorption, protect pancreatic cells from damage, improve insulin release and sensitivity, reduce inflammation, modulate the carbohydrate metabolism pathway, and regulate insulin dependent and independent signalling pathways in diabetic patients15-23.
As a result, scientists are eager to learn more about the mechanisms underlying these polyphenolic compounds' anti-diabetic effects. As a result, the goal of this review is to compile all available data on polyphenols as potential anti-diabetic agents from medicinal plants, fruits, and vegetables, as well as their respective mechanisms. These compounds could be a valuable resource in the future for developing new regimens and/or improving existing synthetic anti-diabetic drugs with fewer or no side effects23.
T1DM affects genetically susceptible people and is thought to be caused by viruses and one or more environmental agents. T1DM individuals' genetic markers, immune markers, and metabolic markers are detectable after birth, after the onset of the autoimmune process, and after the destruction of enough -cells to be detected by sensitive tests. Unfortunately, immunosuppressive drugs rarely prevent autoimmune destruction due to side effects22-24.
Figure 1. A major pathway of Diabetes Mellites, the ROS, are formed in the Oxidative stress via NADPH pathway and the polyol pathway that leads to Nephropathy.
Pharmacological mechanism of natural polyphenols based medicinal antidiabetic agents
Table 1. Major antidiabetic natural polyphenols in natural source25-35
Plant source |
Family |
Common name |
Chemical constituents |
Vaccinium myrtillus L. |
Ericaceae |
European blueberry |
Anthocyanin |
Ipomoea batatas cv.Ayamurasaki |
Convolvulaceae |
Sweet potato |
|
Phaseolus vulgaris |
Fabaceae |
French bean |
|
Lactuca sativa L. |
Asteraceae |
Lettuce |
|
Solanum melongena |
Solanaceae |
Eggplant |
|
Raphanus sativus |
Brassicaceae |
Red radish |
|
Brassicaoleraceavar.capitata f. rubra |
Brassicaceae |
Red cabbage |
|
Allium cepa |
Amaryllidaceae |
Red onion |
|
Asparagus officinalis var. violetto |
Asparagaceae |
Purple asparagus |
|
Solanum tuberosum |
Solanaceae |
Red potato |
|
Brassica oleracea var. botrytis |
Brassicaceae |
Purple cauliflower |
|
Chrysophyllumcainito |
Sapotaceae |
Star apple |
|
Ficuscarica L. |
Moraceae |
Fig |
|
Prunuscerasus |
Rosaceae |
Sour Cherry |
|
Reynosiajamaicensis |
Rhamnaceae |
Blackberry |
|
Rubusrosifolius |
Rosaceae |
Red raspberry |
|
Rubusracemosus |
Rosaceae |
Black raspberry |
|
Kadsuracoccinea |
Schisandraceae |
Black tiger |
|
Prunusarmeniaca L. |
Rosaceae |
Armenian plum/ Apricot |
|
Punica granatum L. |
Lythraceae |
Pomegranate |
Ellagitannin |
Rubus rosifolius |
Rosaceae |
Raspberry |
|
Rubus fruticosus |
Rosaceae |
Blackberry |
|
Dovyalishebecarpa |
Salicaceae |
Ceylon Gooseberry |
|
Fragaria ananassa |
Rosaceae |
Strawberry |
|
Hippo phaerhamnoides |
Elaeagnaceae |
Sea buckthorn berry |
|
Actinidia deliciosa |
Actinidiaceae |
Kiwi |
Luteolin |
Psidium guajava |
Myrtaceae |
Guava |
|
Olea europaea L. |
Oleaceae |
Olive |
|
Citrus paradisi |
Rutaceae |
Grapefruit |
Rosmarinic acids |
Citrus sinensis |
Rutaceae |
Orange |
|
Citrus limon |
Rutaceae |
Lemon |
|
Ribesuva-crispa L. |
Grossulariaceae |
Gooseberry |
Catechin |
Vitisvinifera L. |
Vitaceae |
Black grape |
|
Prunusarmeniaca L. |
Rosaceae |
Apricot |
|
Prunuspersica |
Rosaceae |
Peach |
|
Prunusdomestica |
Rosaceae |
Plum |
|
Prunusavium |
Rosaceae |
Sweet Cherry |
|
Vitisvinifera |
Vitaceae |
White Grape |
|
Diospyros kaki |
Ebenaceae |
Persimmon |
|
Prunusarmeniaca L. |
Rosaceae |
Apricot |
Quercetin |
Maluspumila |
Rosaceae |
Apple |
|
Morus alba |
Moraceae |
Mulberry |
|
Sorbusaucuparia |
Rosaceae |
Rowan |
|
Amelanchieralnifolia |
Rosaceae |
Saskatoon berry |
|
Allium cepa |
Amaryllidaceae |
Onion |
|
Moringa oleifera |
Moringaceae |
Indigenous vegetable |
|
Phaseolus vulgaris |
Fabaceae |
French bean |
|
Pisumsativum |
Fabaceae |
Peas |
|
Solanum lycopersicum |
Solanaceae |
Tomato |
|
Anethumgraveolens |
Apiaceae |
Dill |
|
Brassica napobrassica |
Brassicaceae |
Swedish Turnip |
|
Armoracia rusticana |
Brassicaceae |
Horseradish |
|
Brassica oleracea var. italica |
Brassicaceae |
Broccoli |
|
Vitisrotundifolia |
Vitaceae |
Muscadine grapes |
Resveratrol |
Fragariaananassa |
Rosaceae |
Strawberry |
|
Vaccinium myrtillus |
Ericaceae |
Bilberry |
|
Vacciniumvitis-idaea |
Ericaceae |
Cowberry |
|
Citrus paradisi |
Rutaceae |
Grapefruit |
|
Prunusavium |
Rosaceae |
Sweet Cherry |
Rutin |
Allium Cepa |
Amaryllidaceae |
Onion |
|
Capsicum frutescens |
Solanaceae |
Red pepper |
|
Asparagus officinalis |
Asparagaceae |
Asparagus |
|
Aronias sp. |
Rutaceae |
Aronia |
|
Maluspumila |
Rosaceae |
Apple |
|
Citrus limon |
Rutaceae |
Lemon |
Diosmin |
Citrus aurantifolia |
Rutaceae |
Lime |
|
Maluspumila |
Rosaceae |
Apple |
Myricetin |
Fragariaananassa |
Rosaceae |
Strawberry |
|
Prunusdomestica |
Rosaceae |
Plum |
|
Prunusarmeniaca L. |
Rosaceae |
Apricot |
|
Vitisrotundifolia |
Vitaceae |
Muscadine grapes |
|
Pisumsativum |
Fabaceae |
Peas |
|
Daucuscarota |
Apiaceae |
Carrot |
|
Spinaciaoleracea |
Spinaciaoleracea |
Spinach |
|
Brassica oleracea |
Brassicaceae |
Cauliflower |
|
Brassica rapa |
Brassicaceae |
Turnip |
|
Allium cepa |
Amaryllidaceae |
Onion |
|
Anethumgraveolens |
Apiaceae |
Dill |
|
Apiumgraveolens var. dulce |
Apiaceae |
Celery |
|
Solanum lycopersicum |
Solanaceae |
Tomato |
|
Brassica napobrassica |
Brassicaceae |
Swedish Turnip |
|
Pisumsativum |
Fabaceae |
Peas |
Kaempferol |
Brassica napobrassica |
Brassicaceae |
Swedish Turnip |
|
Armoracia rusticana |
Brassicaceae |
Horse Radish |
|
Brassica oleracea |
Brassicaceae |
Cabbage, Cauliflower |
|
Spinaciaoleracea |
Spinaciaoleracea |
Spinach |
|
Brassica rapa |
Brassicaceae |
Turnip |
|
Brassica oleracea var. italica |
Brassicaceae |
Broccoli |
Major antidiabetic natural polyphenols
DISCUSSION:
Natural products have long been a valuable resource in the development of novel drugs due to their diverse chemical compounds and ability to act on a wide range of biological targets. Polyphenols derived from natural products are currently the focus of drug discovery and development efforts, as many of these compounds are potential therapeutics that can intervene at various stages of diabetes development. Because in vitro and animal studies show that many polyphenols have positive effects on glucose homeostasis, more research on each polyphenol is needed to provide information about their potential to be used as pharmaceutical agents in the treatment of diabetes. Polyphenols found in fruits, vegetables, green tea, and edible plants, as shown in table 1, can be used as prophylactics or as synergistic compounds35-43.
CONFLICT OF INTEREST:
The author has no conflicts of interest.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS:
The author would like to thank NCBI, PubMed and Web of Science for the free database services for their kind support during this study.
REFERENCES:
1. World Health Organization. WHO traditional medicine strategy: 2014-2023. World Health Organization, 2013.
2. World Health Organization. WHO global report on traditional and complementary medicine. 2019. World Health Organization, 2019.
3. World Health Organization. The regional strategy for traditional medicine in the Western Pacific (2011-2020). (2012).
4. World Health Organization. Regional strategy for traditional medicine in the Western Pacific. Manila: WHO Regional Office for the Western Pacific, 2002.
5. Gautam, Y., Dwivedi, S., Srivastava, A., Hamidullah, Singh, A., Chanda, D., Singh, J., Rai, S., Konwar, R., Negi, A.S. 2-(3′,4′-Dimethoxybenzylidene)tetralone induces anti-breast cancer activity through microtubule stabilization and activation of reactive oxygen species. RSC Adv. 2016; 6: 33369–33379.
6. Hamid, A.A., Hasanain, M., Singh, A., Bhukya, B., Omprakash, Vasudev, P.G., Sarkar, J., Chanda, D., Khan, F., Aiyelaagbe, O.O., Negi, A.S. Synthesis of novel anticancer agents through opening of spiroacetal ring of diosgenin. Steroids. 2014; 87: 108–118.
7. Hamid, A.A., Kaushal, T., Ashraf, R., Singh, A., Chand Gupta, A., Prakash, O., Sarkar, J., Chanda, D., Bawankule, D.U., Khan, F., Shanker, K., Aiyelaagbe, O.O., Negi, A.S. (22β,25R)-3β-Hydroxy-spirost-5-en-7-iminoxy-heptanoic acid exhibits anti-prostate cancer activity through caspase pathway. Steroids. 2017; 119: 43–52.
8. Jain, S., Singh, A., Khare, P., Chanda, D., Mishra, D., Shanker, K., Karak, T. Toxicity assessment of Bacopa monnieri L. grown in biochar amended extremely acidic coal mine spoils. Ecological Engineering. 2017;108: 211–219.
9. Khwaja, S., Fatima, K., Hasanain, M., Behera, C., Kour, A., Singh, A., Luqman, S., Sarkar, J., Chanda, D., Shanker, K., Gupta, A.K., Mondhe, D.M., Negi, A.S. Antiproliferative efficacy of curcumin mimics through microtubule destabilization. European Journal of Medicinal Chemistry. 2018; 151: 51–61.
10. Kumar, B.S., Ravi, K., Verma, A.K., Fatima, K., Hasanain, M., Singh, A., Sarkar, J., Luqman, S., Chanda, D., Negi, A.S. Synthesis of pharmacologically important naphthoquinones and anticancer activity of 2-benzyllawsone through DNA topoisomerase-II inhibition. Bioorganic & Medicinal Chemistry. 2017; 25: 1364–1373.
11. Mishra, D., Jyotshna, Singh, A., Chanda, D., Shanker, K., Khare, P. Potential of di-aldehyde cellulose for sustained release of oxytetracycline: A pharmacokinetic study. International Journal of Biological Macromolecules. 2019; 136: 97–105.
12. Sathish Kumar, B., Kumar, A., Singh, J., Hasanain, M., Singh, A., Fatima, K., Yadav, D.K., Shukla, V., Luqman, S., Khan, F., Chanda, D., Sarkar, J., Konwar, R., Dwivedi, A., Negi, A.S. Synthesis of 2-alkoxy and 2-benzyloxy analogues of estradiol as anti-breast cancer agents through microtubule stabilization. European Journal of Medicinal Chemistry. 2014; 86: 740–751.
13. Sathish Kumar, B., Singh, Aastha, Kumar, A., Singh, J., Hasanain, M., Singh, Arjun, Masood, N., Yadav, D.K., Konwar, R., Mitra, K., Sarkar, J., Luqman, S., Pal, A., Khan, F., Chanda, D., Negi, A.S. Synthesis of neolignans as microtubule stabilisers. Bioorganic & Medicinal Chemistry. 2014; 22: 1342–1354.
14. Singh, A., Mohanty, I., Singh, J., Rattan, S., 2020. BDNF augments rat internal anal sphincter smooth muscle tone via RhoA/ROCK signaling and nonadrenergic noncholinergic relaxation via increased NO release. American Journal of Physiology-Gastrointestinal and Liver Physiology. 2020; 318: G23–G33.
15. Singh, A., Rattan, S. BDNF rescues aging-associated internal anal sphincter dysfunction. American Journal of Physiology-Gastrointestinal and Liver Physiology. 2021; 321: G87–G97.
16. Singh, A., Singh, J., Rattan, S. Evidence for the presence and release of BDNF in the neuronal and non‐neuronal structures of the internal anal sphincter. Neurogastroenterology & Motility. 2021.
17. Singh, Aastha, Fatima, K., Singh, Arjun, Behl, A., Mintoo, M.J., Hasanain, M., Ashraf, R., Luqman, S., Shanker, K., Mondhe, D.M., Sarkar, J., Chanda, D., Negi, A.S. Anticancer activity and toxicity profiles of 2-benzylidene indanone lead molecule. European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences. 2015; 76: 57–67.
18. Singh, Aastha, Fatima, K., Srivastava, A., Khwaja, S., Priya, D., Singh, Arjun, Mahajan, G., Alam, S., Saxena, A.K., Mondhe, D.M., Luqman, S., Chanda, D., Khan, F., Negi, A.S. Anticancer activity of gallic acid template-based benzylidene indanone derivative as microtubule destabilizer. Chem Biol Drug Des. 2016; 88: 625–634.
19. Manmohan, S., Arjun, S., Khan, S. P., Eram, S., Sachan, N. K., 2012. Green chemistry potential for past, present and future perspectives. International Research Journal of Pharmacy, 3, 31-36.
20. Singh A, Kumar BS, Alam S, Iqbal H, Shafiq M, Khan F, Negi AS, Hanif K, Chanda D. Corrigendum to "Diethyl-4,4'-dihydroxy-8,3'-neolign-7,7'-dien-9,9'-dionate exhibits AH activity in rats through increase in intracellular cGMP level and blockade of calcium channels" [Eur. J. Pharmacol. 799 (2017) 84-93]. Eur J Pharmacol. 2017 Jul 5;806:111. doi: 10.1016/j.ejphar.2017.04.033. Erratumfor: Eur J Pharmacol. 2017 Mar 15;799:84-93. PMID: 28495016.
21. Singh, A., R. Sharma, K. M. Anand, S. P. Khan, and N. K. Sachan. Food-drug interaction. International Journal of Pharmaceutical & Chemical Science. 2012; 1(1): 264-279.
22. Arjun Singh. A Review of various aspects of the Ethnopharmacological, Phytochemical, Pharmacognostical, and Clinical significance of selected Medicinal plants. Asian Journal of Pharmacy and Technology. 2022; 12(4): 349-0. doi: 10.52711/2231-5713.2022.00055
23. Pushpendra Kumar, Titi Xavier Mangalathil, Vikas Choudhary. An experimental study to assess the effectiveness of structured teaching programme on knowledge regarding the management of diabetes mellitus among G.N.M. students in selected nursing school at Sikar, Rajasthan. Asian J. Management. 2014; 5(3): 329-331.
24. Harpreet Kaur. Effectiveness of structured teaching programme regarding self care management in relation to prevention of complications among diabetics. Asian J. Nur. Edu. & Research. 2014; 4(3): 279-283.
25. Thressia. P.A. (Sr. Tresa Anto) , Rajeev. Kumar. N.. Effect of Sleep Duration on Obesity and the Glycemic level in Patients with Type 2 Diabetes. Asian J. Nur. Edu. and Research. 2014; 4(4): 502-507.
26. Hazaratali Panari, Vegunarani. M. Study on Complications of Diabetes Mellitus among the Diabetic Patients. Asian J. Nur. Edu. and Research. 2016; 6(2): 171-182.
27. Radhika C. K., Asha Raj. Uremic Hypoglycemia. Asian J. Nur. Edu. and Research. 2017; 7(3): 445-448.
28. Parisa Parsa, Roya Ahmadinia-Tabesh, Younes Mohammadi. Assessment of the risk of Coronary Heart Disease in Diabetes Patients Type-II. Asian J. Nursing Education and Research. 2019; 9(2): 267-270.
29. Jyoti Thakur . Effect of Maternal Diabetes on Fetus and Newborn. Asian J. Nursing Education and Research. 2019; 9(3): 463-465.
30. Rajesh Joshi. A Descriptive Study of the Prevalence of Diabetes Mellitus among Peoples residing in Valam Village, Mehsana, Gujarat. Asian J. Nursing Education and Research. 2020; 10(1): 23-24.
31. Lakshmi. K. Effectiveness of Nursing care of antenatal mothers with Gestational diabetes mellitus. Asian J. Nursing Education and Research. 2020; 10(3): 286-290.
32. Shom Prakash Kushwaha, Sunil Kumar Rawat, Pavan Kumar, Abhishek ,Kishu Tripathi. Coupling Antioxidant and Antidiabetic assets of 2, 4-Thiazolidinedione Derivatives. Asian J. Pharm. Ana. 2011; 1(4): 71-73.
33. Bairwa Ranjan, Jain Honey, Shrivastav Birendra. Standardization and phytochemical investigation of Berberis aristata. Asian J. Pharm. Ana. 2012; 2(3): 81-84.
34. Shobha Rani G, Lohita M, Jaya Preethi P, Madhavi R, Sunisitha B, Mounika D. Glimepiride: A Review of Analytical Methods. Asian J. Pharm. Ana. 2014; 4(4): 178-182.
35. Omkar A. Patil, Indrajeet S. Patil, Ganesh B. Vambhurkar, Dheeraj S. Randive, Mangesh A. Bhutkar, Srinivas K. Mohite. UV Spectroscopic Degradation Study of Pioglitazone Hydrochloride. Asian J. Pharm. Ana. 2018; 8(3):125-128.
36. Dharmesh Sharma, Deepak Prashar, Sanjay Saklani. Bird’s Eye View on Herbal Treatment of Diabetes. Asian J. Pharm. Res. 2012; 2(1): 1-6.
37. Arjun Singh. A Review of various aspects of the Ethnopharmacological, Phytochemical, Pharmacognostical, and Clinical significance of selected Medicinal plants. Asian Journal of Pharmacy and Technology. 2022; 12(4): 349-0. doi: 10.52711/2231-5713.2022.00055
38. Devender Paswan, Urmila Pande, Alka Singh, Divya Sharma, Shivani Kumar, Arjun Singh. Epidemiology, Genomic Organization, and Life Cycle of SARS CoV-2. Asian Journal of Nursing Education and Research. 2023; 13(2):141-4.
39. Arjun Singh, Rupendra Kumar, Sachin Sharma. Natural products and Hypertension: Scope and role in Antihypertensive Therapy. Asian Journal of Nursing Education and Research. 2023; 13(2): 162-6.
40. Arjun Singh. A Review of various aspects of the Ethnopharmacological, Phytochemical, Pharmacognostical, and Clinical significance of selected Medicinal plants. Asian Journal of Pharmacy and Technology. 2022; 12(4): 349-0.
41. Arjun Singh, Rupendra Kumar. An Overview on Ethnopharmacological, Phytochemical, and Clinical Significance of Selected Dietary Polyphenols. Asian Journal of Research in Chemistry. 2023; 16(1):8-2.
42. Arjun Singh. Plant-based Isoquinoline Alkaloids: A Chemical and Pharmacological Profile of Some Important Leads. Asian Journal of Research in Chemistry. 2023; 16(1):43-8.
43. Singh, A., Chanda, D., and Negi, A. S. (2018). Antihypertensive activity of Diethyl-4, 4'-dihydroxy-8, 3'-neolign-7, 7'-dien-9, 9'-dionate through increase in intracellular cGMP level and blockade of calcium channels (VDCC) and opening of potassium channel and in vivo models (SHRs and L-NAME induced hypertension). In Proceedings for Annual Meeting of The Japanese Pharmacological Society WCP2018 (The 18th World Congress of Basic and Clinical Pharmacology) (pp. PO1-2). Japanese Pharmacological Society.
Received on 22.12.2022 Modified on 04.05.2023
Accepted on 26.07.2023 ©A&V Publications All right reserved
Res. J. Pharmacology and Pharmacodynamics.2024;16(1):42-47.
DOI: 10.52711/2321-5836.2024.00008